We have just experienced our redemption from Egypt, we experienced the splitting of the Red Sea and the singing of the Shira. The Redemption of Egypt is the prototype for our final redemption. We have seen many signs over the last 77 years that indicate that we are approaching the final redemption, but why aren’t we there yet?
Is Mashiach Waiting for Us?
In “Siach Nechama,” Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky wrote that the Mashiach is alive and already with us—and that the redemption is fully prepared. It will come the moment Am Yisrael merits it.
That was several years ago. So why hasn’t the Mashiach revealed himself yet?
Over the past 18 months, Hashem has shown us open miracles. Hundreds of Iranian and Houthi missiles have failed to cause significant harm. Countless personal miracles have taken place across Israel. A spiritual awakening is underway—Jews are returning to mitzvot, putting on tefillin, wearing tzitzit, keeping Shabbat. Torah learning is booming throughout the Diaspora.
And still, no redemption.
The Rambam gives us a clear sign of Mashiach’s approach: “The very sign that Mashiach is on the way is when Jews from all over the Diaspora make Aliyah.” (Laws of Kings, 11:1)
The Voices of Our Gedolim
- Rav Yitzchok Breuer said: “It was Hashem who exiled us—but it was our sins that distanced us from our Land. The distancing was our own doing.”
- Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld taught: “Anyone who has the ability to come to Eretz Yisrael and does not will have to account for it in the World to Come.”
- Rabbi Shlomo Aviner observed: “People don’t make aliyah because they are in love with the exile and don’t want to give it up. Rabbis must make aliyah a central part of Jewish education.”
But It’s a Big Decision
Of course it is. Aliyah affects your entire family—career, finances, education, comfort zone. But many of the common objections are less overwhelming than they seem. Here are a few, with some perspective:
- I Have a Great Job in America
Israel has a booming economy—fourth strongest in the world. Salaries may be lower, but healthcare and education are much more affordable. Many jobs are now remote or in-demand in Israel.
- My Elderly Parents Need Me
This is a real concern—but Israel is one of the most elderly-friendly countries in the world, with better healthcare, higher life expectancy, and deep cultural respect for seniors.
- My Children Are Too Old to Adapt
Yes, transitions are tough between ages 7-16. But today there are Anglo-focused schools, youth programs, and strong support systems to help your kids thrive.
- I Love American Culture
So much of American culture—innovation, individuality, creativity—is also thriving in Israel. You may miss some things, but you’ll find plenty of cultural vibrancy in return.
- My Children/Grandchildren Are Here
True, it’s hard. But many olim report that they spend more meaningful time with family post-aliyah, because visits are more intentional and focused.
- The Cost of Living Is Too High
Prices are rising everywhere—but competition in Israel is increasing, and the savings on healthcare and tuition are major. Financial planning makes a big difference.
- I Don’t Speak Hebrew
English is widely spoken, especially in Anglo communities. There’s ulpan, Nefesh B’Nefesh programs, and plenty of people willing to help.
- I’m Afraid of Change
We’ve all faced big changes—marriage, moving, new jobs. Change is hard, but it’s often the door to growth.
- My Rabbi Isn’t Going
Many American rabbis stay to support those still in the Diaspora. But a large number do make aliyah after retirement.
- I Don’t Like the Israeli Government
Governments change. Over half the Knesset is shomer Shabbat. The best way to have a voice in Israel’s future is to live there and vote.
Other Objections?
You enjoy a two-day Yom Tov? You want more time to “get mitzvot right” first? Florida is warmer? We all have rationalizations. But they deserve honest reflection.
The Bottom Line
Yes, making aliyah is a major decision. It deserves serious thought. But don’t let fear, comfort, or misinformation be your guide. Research. Ask questions. Listen to the gedolim. Look at what’s unfolding in our world.
We pray every day to return to Zion. Hashem is showing us the door. Will we walk through it?
So, when you meet that “aliyah zealot,” remember: They may just be holding up a mirror. Take a moment to ask: What’s really holding me back?
Because Mashiach is already here.
He’s just waiting for you to come home.
Rabbi Paul D. Bloom lives in Jerusalem and Edison, New Jersey with his wife, Ettie. He is a retired IBM executive and is currently the CEO of PDB Futurecom International. He is on the board of directors of NY/ Israel Chamber of Commerce, Dollar a Day of Raritan Valley and the Israel Inspiration Initiative.
