June 12, 2024
Close this search box.
Close this search box.
June 12, 2024
Close this search box.

Linking Northern and Central NJ, Bronx, Manhattan, Westchester and CT

Cutting Through the Noise: Sobering Thoughts About Purim

In days such as ours, Purim speaks to us in a different—and necessary—way.

On Purim things get all turned around. It’s a theme of the day. Maybe that’s why Jews do things on Purim they don’t do all year long. They make lots of noise in the synagogue. [Of course, you never do that!] Some drink so much that they don’t know who’s the good guy and who’s the bad one. [Ditto!!] They even put on costumes and masks. [Well, some of us wear masks all the time. We just don’t admit it.]

In keeping with this turnabout theme of Purim, let’s do something people usually don’t do on or about Purim: Let’s get serious. Seriously! We shouldn’t conceive of Purim as being a Hebraic Mardi Gras, a Jewish mutation of New Year’s Eve and Halloween. There’s got to be more to this holiday. Of course there is. You expected it, didn’t you? Well, like a hamantash, here are three Purim points—sober ones. No joke.

1. Drowned out by the noise at the Megillah reading are Purim’s other prescribed activities: the Fast of Esther, sending food to friends, giving gifts to the needy, and joining together for a joyous yet religiously oriented meal. Okay, we’ve had a long, bitter history of suppression. It’s natural to want to rejoice at an enemy’s defeat. But that’s not the thrust of a single Purim mitzvah! Look at the list. It suggests, rather, a drawing together among Jews—a call for unity and community at all levels, in all ways, among all economic classes, with family, friends and strangers.

Maybe this suggests an answer to Purim’s unasked question: Why did Purim occur? Why did the Jews find themselves in a position of utter destruction? It isn’t only God who has to be “One” but also God’s people. Early rabbinic commentaries suggest discord among the Jews of Esther’s time. Some Jews chose to go to the king’s party. They drank and took part in the “fun.” Jewish moderation and decency went out the window. Other Jews saw the dangers and stayed away. But they didn’t reach out to their fellows. Instead, they chose to separate themselves from the others—for the sake of their own religious preservation. Mordechai and Esther understood we are all in the same boat. They cared enough and loved enough to extend themselves, even to the point of endangering their lives. Therefore they could bring the Jews back into one cohesive and viable community. They formalized the lesson by instituting rituals and activities that foster Jewish unity. These rituals create within us a common Jewish memory, warm friendships and caring behaviors. They work.

2. Did you know that Megillat Esther is one of the only two books of the Bible in which God’s name does not appear? The other is Shir Hashirim, the Song of Songs. There’s absolutely no clear mention of God’s presence or role. But look closely. You can see God’s hand. As the Talmud says, “God creates the cure before the illness.” Vashti falls. The king sends out ludicrous decrees. Esther becomes queen. Mordechai saves the king’s life. The king owes him big time, but forgets. All this before Haman ascends to a position where he can do us harm. And on just the right night the king can’t sleep and is reminded he owes Mordechai. And just after Haman accidentally trips, the king returns to Esther’s chamber to see Haman fall on her… couch. And another adviser points out that Haman was about to execute the king’s friend, Mordechai. His Majesty smells a conspiracy and destroys the enemy of the Jews. We may not always see the hand of God too clearly, but it is there, even in our times. Have faith.

3. Megillat Esther is the latest book chronologically canonized in the Bible. Because it takes place in the Diaspora, it’s full of lessons for Jews on how to survive in a Diaspora environment where we don’t have the power of our own government. Its suggestions include that:

We must be alert always to what is happening around us.

We should negotiate when we can and act quickly when we can’t.

We should develop alliances. Mordechai heard the plans of the assassins and later of Haman and acted through friends.

We can be in the world, but we don’t have to act like everyone else in it. “There was a Jewish man who lived in the castle of Shushan [Esther 2:5].” Mordechai’s greatness was that he wasn’t only a good Jew at home, in the synagogue, or with fellow Jews, but also in the streets and royal offices of Shushan. He didn’t leave home without it!

Megillat Esther also tells us that:

There are times to wear masks and times to take them off.

There are times to bow and times to stand tall.

We need to know that there are times to forgive and times when we cannot.

And its last verse hints that no matter how successful we may be or want to be on the outside, our Jewish home and family must come first. They are our havens.

See, there’s much more to Purim than noise, graggers and hamantashen. But did you really think I could let you get away without one Purim joke??!!

Moishe was a waiter at Max’s Delicatessen for 40 years. He was a fixture. But like all good things, he dies.

His friends want to say one last goodbye, so they organize a seance. The medium says, “Just give a knock on the table like you used to do to get his attention—and he will appear.” So they knock on the table. No Moishe. They knock again. No Moishe. They start to call his name and yell. Suddenly he appears with a towel over his arm. “So where were you,” they demanded, “when we knocked and knocked?”

“It’s not my table.”

The joke may not have anything to do with Purim, but I think it’s funny. Okay, so maybe they ordered a prune hamantash.

Chaim Lauer is a Jewish educator and communal professional, author and speaker, known for his programmatic creativity and teaching skills. For over 50 years he has served the Jewish community in various professional capacities, leading Federations, Boards of Jewish Education, and consulting with other national and local organizations.

Leave a Comment

Most Popular Articles