Highlighting: “State of Halakha” by Aviad Tabory. Maggid Books. 2023. English. Hardcover. 304 pages. ISBN-13: 978-1592645534.
(Courtesy of Koren)
The Declaration of Independence, 1948
Can Yom Ha’atzmaut Be Celebrated Earlier Than the Original Date?
On Friday, May 14, 1948, David Ben-Gurion declared Israel’s independence. The Hebrew date was 5 Iyar 5708. The declaration, which took place in Tel Aviv, was scheduled about eight hours before the end of the British mandate at midnight on Shabbat. The leaders of the Jewish community in Palestine at the time were aware that the result of such a move would be an immediate invasion by the surrounding Arab nations.
The decision was not an easy one. The opposition, both external and internal, was strong and fierce. Many of Ben-Gurion’s advisers urged him to postpone the declaration. For many years, it was rumored that the final vote for the declaration had passed by a slight majority—six to four.
Even though the White House supported the move, the State Department was vehemently opposed. The following description of events by Clark Clifford, a close adviser of President Truman, contains valuable insight into the opposition faced by Israel:
The President regarded his Secretary of State, General of the Army George C. Marshall, as “the greatest living American.” Yet the two men were on a collision course over Mideast policy, which, if not resolved, threatened to split and wreck the Administration. British control of Palestine would run out in two days, and when it did, the Jewish Agency intended to announce the creation of a new state, still unnamed, in part of Palestine.
Marshall firmly opposed American recognition of the new Jewish state…. Marshall’s opposition was shared by almost every member of the brilliant and now-legendary group of men, later referred to as “the Wise Men,” who were then in the process of creating a postwar foreign policy that would endure for more than forty years…
Some months earlier, during one of our weekly breakfasts at his elegant Georgetown home, Forrestal [James Vincent Forrestal, the secretary of defense] had spoken emotionally and frankly to me concerning his opposition to helping the Zionists, as advocates of the creation of a Jewish state were called. “You fellows over at the White House are just not facing up to the realities in the Middle East. There are thirty million Arabs on one side and about six hundred thousand Jews on the other. It is clear that in any contest, the Arabs are going to overwhelm the Jews. Why don’t you face up to the realities? Just look at the numbers!”
As noted, within Ben-Gurion’s own cabinet there was fierce opposition to declaring the state. On the day the cabinet had to vote on the proposal, discouraging news arrived both from the king of Jordan, who replied negatively to Israel’s request for a truce, and from Moshe Sharett (appointed foreign minister that very week), who informed Ben-Gurion that not only would America not recognize the new Jewish state, but in the inevitable war which would follow any kind of declaration, the United States would not come to Israel’s aid.
Nobel Prize laureate S. Y. Agnon describes the courage it took for Ben-Gurion to make the decision:
We all wanted a Jewish state. Of course we did. But we were afraid of saying so out loud. And when the test came, we thought perhaps we should not risk it, perhaps we should postpone it for a generation, but Ben-Gurion had the courage to proclaim the end of Jewish statelessness in our time.
Yom Ha’atzmaut and Its Halakhic Implications
Rabbi Tzvi Yehuda Kook (Jerusalem, 1891-1982) explored the unique kedushat hayom (sanctity of the day) of Yom Ha’atzmaut in a passionate address. He explains that the greatest miracle of the establishment of the State of Israel was not the military victory of a fledgling state over the armies of enemy countries, but the remarkable courage to make that fateful decision and announce the establishment of an independent state. He defends this idea by quoting the Gemara (Bava Metzia 106a), which states that a shepherd’s rescue of his flock from a lion or a bear may be considered a miracle. Where exactly is the miracle in this act? The Tosafists explain that the miracle is to be found in the shepherd’s “spirit of courage and willingness to fight.” This spirit of valor is a miracle from above, an inspired inner greatness spurring one to rise to the needs of the hour.
Similarly, Sephardi Chief Rabbi Ben-Zion Uziel writes about the ramifications of the declaration itself:
“This day you have become the people of the Lord your God” (Deut. 27:9), because on this day we were released from the enslavement of a foreign kingdom in the Land of Israel, which wanted to choke us to death.
This daring declaration has made the Jewish people into an independent nation. It has given courage to the soldiers of Israel and it has opened up the gates of the Land of Israel to all Jews scattered around the world. This declaration has enabled the Jewish people to take their rightful place as a nation among the nations of the world. “This is the day the Lord has made; let us rejoice and be glad in it” (Ps. 118:24)
Both rabbis emphasize, each in his own way, the significance that the declaration itself plays within the miraculous events of 1948. Do these opinions have halakhic ramifications?
Since 1949, the observant world has celebrated Yom Ha’atzmaut both as a religious day and as a national holiday. Questions have been asked about reciting Hallel, the Sheheĥeyanu blessing (“Who has kept us alive”; the blessing for special occasions), and the SheAsa Nissim blessing (“Who has performed miracles”). Many articles and books deal with these subjects.
Blessing on Yom Ha’atzmaut
In one of the many discussions about reciting Sheheĥeyanu, Rabbi Yehoshua Menachem Ehrenberg (Hungary/Israel, 1904-1976) argues against reciting the blessing. He explains the difference between Yom Ha’atzmaut and Ĥanukka in the following way: While the miraculous events of Ĥanukka actually took place beginning on 25 Kislev, the miracles which we celebrate on our Independence Day occurred either on the last day of the 1948 war, when the ceasefire was signed, or on November 29, 1947, the day the UN voted for the Partition Plan. Thus, no miracle actually occurred on the fifth of Iyar. Therefore, he concludes, the blessing should not be recited. Obviously, based on the views of Rabbis Kook and Uziel, one could argue the opposite.
Hallel on the Fifth of Iyar
The fifth of Iyar was designated by the Israeli government as the official day to celebrate Israel’s independence, and a law was passed to that effect. Israel’s Remembrance Day for fallen soldiers, Yom Hazikaron, was set on the previous day, the fourth of Iyar. However, concerns about the desecration of Shabbat over the years have necessitated moving these days. Thus, if the fifth of Iyar falls on Friday or Shabbat, Yom Ha’atzmaut is moved to Thursday and Yom Hazikaron to Wednesday; if the fourth of Iyar falls on Sunday, Yom Hazikaron is pushed off until Monday and Yom Ha’atzmaut to Tuesday. (This was codified by the Knesset in 1950 as an amendment to the Yom Ha’atzmaut law.) The result is that in most cases Ha’atzma’ut is not celebrated on its original date of the fifth of Iyar. The rabbis discuss the proper halakhic response to this situation.
Chief Rabbi Shlomo Goren (Poland/Israel, 1917-1994) argues that even if the national day has been changed to a different date, Hallel must be recited on the original date, the fifth of Iyar. His reasoning is that the sources that require us to recite Hallel on miraculous days seem to indicate that the prayer can only be recited on the actual day of the historical miraculous event. He quotes Rabbi Menachem Meiri (on Pesaĥim 117a), who argues that any person who has been saved miraculously from danger may celebrate that date every year with the recital of Hallel. He then cites the Ĥatam Sofer (Rabbi Moshe Sofer; Pressburg, 1762-1839; Yoreh De’ah 133), who believes that celebrating a holiday and reciting Hallel for miracles may be based on a biblical source. Both sources, argues Rabbi Goren, limit the celebrations to the actual date itself. Rabbi Goren maintains, as a matter of fact, that all salvation and victories in the 1948 war are connected to the fifth of Iyar, the day the nation of Israel declared its independence.
A further reason for his ruling has to do with the original decision to celebrate Yom Ha’atzmaut on the fifth of Iyar each year. Rabbi Goren argues that the original decision did not take into account the possibilities of changing the date; the changes, therefore, cannot be made today.
Today’s custom, however, is to celebrate Yom Ha’atzmaut with the recital of Hallel on the day chosen by the state. Rabbi Yaakov Ariel, in an article on this topic, explains that there is a precedent for this in Jewish law. When Purim falls on Shabbat (in our calendar, this would be when Shushan Purim is observed on Shabbat in Jerusalem and other walled cities), the reading of the Megilla is pushed back to Friday while the other commandments of the day are celebrated either on Sunday or on Shabbat. The reading of the Megilla, claims R. Naĥman in the Gemara (Megilla 14a), is parallel to Hallel, proving that Hallel can be recited on an alternative date.
Nevertheless, some might argue that we divide the days’ commandments differently. On the alternative date, we should celebrate the national side of Yom Ha’atzmaut together as an entire state, but we should maintain the religious side of Yom Ha’atzmaut on Shabbat (as Rabbi Goren suggests). Rabbi Ariel strongly disagrees. In this case, he argues, we would be committing the terrible “sin” of creating a separation between religion and state. The message would be that the national side of Yom Ha’atzmaut is separate from the religious dimension.
Rabbi Yaakov Medan addresses this question and concurs with Rabbi Ariel.He brings to our attention that, as noted earlier, Ben-Gurion himself declared independence on Friday, May 14, even though the official date for the expiration of the mandate was May 15. This was due to his consideration of not desecrating the Shabbat. Even from the very beginning, the date of Yom Ha’atzmaut was based upon the consideration of not violating Shabbat.
The Jewish nation’s declaration of sovereignty in its land posed halakhic questions that the religious leadership had to answer. Ultimately, after the rabbis debated this matter, their ruling became the custom practiced by Israelis and Jews worldwide.