On March 20, Danish Minister of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries, Dan Jorgensen, met a delegation of European Muslim and Jewish leaders who informed him that his edict last month banning kosher and halal slaughtering is doing grave damage to the image of Denmark in Europe and the United States and should be rescinded as soon as possible.
Responding to an assurance from Jorgensen that he had been misquoted in the media for allegedly having said, “Animal rights come before religion” at the time that he promulgated the ban on kosher and halal slaughtering last month, Muslim-Jewish delegation participant Alexander Goldberg, Jewish Chaplain at the University of Surrey in the UK, stated, “We will judge you not by your words, but by your actions. So far, those actions show that you indeed put animal rights before religious rights.”
Jorgensen told the delegation that the decision to ban slaughter without prior stunning of the animal was not something he initiated on his own, but rather the Danish government carrying out a directive of the European Union, of which Denmark is a member. However, Samia Hathroubi, European coordinator of the Foundation for Ethnic Understanding and a delegation member from France, pointed out that the EU allows exceptions to this directive to religious communities such as Muslims and Jews, whose ritual slaughtering practices proscribe stunning, and countries like France and Belgium have specifically sanctioned such exceptions. Delegation members pointed out that Muslims and Jews worldwide believe that their respective venerable practices of ritual slaughter are performed in a manner that ensures that the animal suffers the least possible pain during slaughtering.
Jorgensen stressed that while he stands by his ban on kosher and halal slaughtering in Denmark, he will allow the Danish Jewish and Muslim communities to continue to import kosher and halal meat products. Jorgensen told the delegation that he has sought to prevent debate on the issue from moving to the streets of Denmark, because if it were to do so most Danes would support a no-exceptions ban on the consumption of meat butchered according to kosher and halal slaughtering techniques because of widespread anti-Muslim sentiment in the country. Members of the delegation responded that by promulgating the ban the Danish government is essentially giving support to anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish bigots by validating their argument that kosher and halal slaughtering techniques are inhumane.
Goldberg informed Jorgensen that he recently met with a top aide to US Secretary of State John Kerry, who told him that Kerry recently expressed concern that the Danish decision to ban kosher slaughtering, together with similar acts by other European countries, raises concerns as to whether Jewish life in Europe will be sustainable going forward. Delegation members reported that there is grave concern among Muslims and Jews across the continent that the Danish ban will trigger a domino effect that will force Muslims and Jews to leave Europe.
According to Chief Rabbi of Strasbourg, Rene Gutman, “We forcefully made the point to the Minister that Denmark, a country known as a champion of human rights and religious freedom going back to the successful evacuation of Danish Jews to Sweden during the Nazi occupation, will now be known as a country that prevents its Muslim and Jewish citizens from practicing fundamental precepts of their faiths unhindered.” Afzal Khan, former Lord Mayor of Manchester and co-founder of the Muslim-Jewish Forum of Greater Manchester, remarked, “We made clear to Minister Jorgensen that we will continue our campaign of international pressure on Denmark until it realizes the great hurt it is causing Muslims and Jews at home and worldwide, and rescinds this ruinous policy.”
Participants in the Muslim-Jewish delegation that met with Minister Jorgensen included:
1. Chief Rabbi of Brussels, Albert Guigui (Belgium)
2. Afzal Khan, former Lord Mayor of Manchester and co-founder of the Muslim-Jewish Forum of Greater Manchester (UK)
3. Chief Rabbi of Strasbourg, Rene Gutman (France)
4. Samia Hathroubi, FFEU European Coordinator (France)
5. Alexander Goldberg, Jewish Chaplain, University of Surrey (UK)
6. Moussa Al-Hassan Diaw, Director, Department of Islamic Theology, University of Osnabruck (Germany)
7. Chief Rabbi of Denmark Bent Lexner
8. Kamran Shah, Religious Advisor to the Islamic Community of Denmark
Rabbi Marc Schneier, President of FFEU, said participants in the delegation came from the United Kingdom, France, Belgium, Germany and Denmark under the aegis of the New York-based foundation and its affiliate, the Gathering of European Muslim and Jewish Leaders (GEMJL).
