May 24, 2024
Close this search box.
Close this search box.
May 24, 2024
Close this search box.

Linking Northern and Central NJ, Bronx, Manhattan, Westchester and CT

A few weeks ago, at the end of November, I had the pleasure of attending the therapist track at the Agudah Convention. On Thursday and Friday of the convention weekend there were lectures and presentations specifically geared for therapists. It was also an opportunity to network and meet colleagues in the field.

Aside for the great insights and connections I was able to forge, one of the highlights for me actually had nothing to do with therapy or counseling.

On Friday morning after Shacharis, I went to the dining room for breakfast. As with all the meals, there was quite a spread for breakfast, with many delicious choices.

After selecting my meal, I placed my breakfast on a table, including a steaming omelet made to my specification from the omelet station. When I went to get a drink, I noticed that Rabbi Shloime Mandel, the rosh yeshiva of Yeshiva of Brooklyn, had just sat down to eat breakfast as well.

I met Rabbi Mandel when he came to Camp Dora Golding for davening for a few days during previous summers while he had been vacationing in the Poconos. Due to COVID restrictions he hadn’t been there the previous two summers. I approached the rosh yeshiva and introduced myself, noting that we missed seeing him in camp and hoped we would be graced with his visit again this coming summer. He smiled and said there was a story behind those visits to camp. He asked me if my wife was waiting for me. When I replied that she wasn’t at the convention he shared the story.

He began that one summer a few decades back; he had been looking to get away for a few days. He was looking for a somewhat remote location that had three minyanim daily. Someone informed him that there was a place called Camp Dora Golding that had only Russian campers.

I told Rabbi Mandel that it must have been the summer of 1995. At the time Camp Dora Golding only had 70 campers, and Camp Kesharim—a camp for Jewish boys from Russia—rented out half of the camp.[1]

I’ll continue the story in his words.

“I called the camp to find out what time Ma’ariv was. When I arrived and walked into the shul assuming I wouldn’t know anyone, I immediately saw a young man who lived on my block in Brooklyn making a beeline across the room toward me. He was a counselor in the camp, and he wanted to know if he could bring Alex, a 15-year-old camper of his, over to meet me to ask me a question. I asked him what Alex’s story was. My neighbor explained that Alex was the best camper in the camp. He was deeply motivated and loved davening and learning. In fact, he knew the entire Pirkei Avos by heart. But Alex didn’t have a bris milah. A few years earlier, when he first began learning and was excited to become more observant, his parents gave him the choice of either having a bris milah or attending yeshiva, but not both.[2]

“Meanwhile, Ma’ariv was beginning, and Alex happened to be the chazan. I was very moved by Alex’s sincere and heartfelt davening. Afterward, his counselor indeed brought him over to me and Alex presented his question. He began by asking me if Moshe was the greatest tzaddik ever. I replied that I definitely am not one to decide who was the greatest, but there’s no doubt that he is one of the greatest people who ever lived. Alex then quoted the Mishnah in Pirkei Avos that states that “One should nullify his own will because of the Will of Hashem”[3]. Then he asked, ‘If Hashem didn’t want Moshe Rabbeinu to enter Eretz Yisrael, why did Moshe keep davening—515 times in all—that Hashem allow him to enter the Land? Shouldn’t the great Moshe have pushed aside his own deep desire if Hashem didn’t want it?’

“As I listened to his question, tears welled up in my eyes. I realized Alex was really asking about himself. He so badly wanted to attend a yeshiva, and it was clear that he constantly davened to have that opportunity. As his prayers had not yet been answered, he wondered if perhaps it was wrong to continue praying when it seemed that it wasn’t Hashem’s Will.

“I replied that there is a concept that Hashem will sometimes withhold blessing temporarily because He wants the person to continue davening, so that their prayer can be granted in a greater fashion. Something attained because of prayer is holier and loftier. It was for that reason that the patriarchs and matriarchs only merited children after years of tears and prayer.[4]

“During the time when he davened 515 times, Moshe Rabbeinu was unaware that Hashem didn’t want him to enter the Land. Moshe thought it was incumbent upon him to continue praying, just as the patriarchs and matriarchs had done[5].

“Indeed, as soon as Hashem instructed him to stop praying, he did so, and never asked again if he could enter the Land.

“The message to Alex was that he should never stop davening, because, unlike Moshe Rabbeinu, he had never been told to restrain himself from davening. Oftentimes great things require extra prayers, tears and patience.”

I thanked Rabbi Mandel for the beautiful story, but he then added the following addendum:

“While reflecting back on that incident a few years later, I was wondering to myself why Hashem used such strong words when instructing Moshe to stop davening to enter the Land: “Do not continue to speak to Me anymore about this matter![6]” Why didn’t He simply tell Moshe that it wasn’t His will for Him to enter, and that it wouldn’t bode well for the nation? Why the seemingly harsh commandment?

“The Gemara[7] asks why Moshe so yearned to enter Eretz Yisrael. It surely wasn’t because he wanted to try out the restaurants or see the tourist attractions. The Gemara explains that Moshe desired to perform the unique mitzvos endemic to the Land. Despite all he had done and accomplished throughout his life, he still felt spiritually malnourished and wanted to serve Hashem in every way possible.

“Perhaps it was in response to that deep desire that Hashem instructed Moshe to not daven again about that matter. ‘Moshe, you love mitzvos and desire to serve me in ways you didn’t have the chance to do before. Therefore, I will give you a “mitzvah” that no one before or after had. It is the mitzvah for you not to daven for the matter that you desire so much.’

“In this way, for the remainder of his life, whenever Moshe wanted to daven to enter the Land and would restrain himself from doing so, he would be serving Hashem in a most unique fashion.”

Rabbi Mandel continued:

“About six years ago I had the opportunity to have a private audience with Rav Chaim Kanievsky. While there, Rav Chaim noticed my wristwatch and motioned that I should remove it.[8] Anyone who knows me knows that I’m extremely punctual and conscientious about time, and I couldn’t hide my disappointment at Rav Chaim’s instruction. When Rav Chaim noticed that I wasn’t happy about removing my watch, he said that I should put a clock on the wall. When he saw that I was still not happy, he humorously said that I can wear the watch on my foot. When I replied that then I would be ‘l’ma’alah min hazman—above time,’ Rav Chaim laughed heartily. But then he said that I could wear a pocket watch.”

At that point, Rabbi Mandel opened his jacket and showed me that he was wearing a pocket watch. He noted that it was very difficult for him to make the transition, but whenever he thinks about it, he feels good, knowing that he is constantly listening to the instruction of a tzaddik, and thereby fulfilling a unique mitzvah.”

Rabbi Mandel’s poignant message was that we serve Hashem not only by fulfilling His will, but also by restraining ourselves from doing things we want, and that too is an integral way of fulfilling His will.

The same is true regarding all relationships. It’s not only about what we do, but also about what we don’t do, in honor and deference to our spouse, friend or neighbor.

It’s an invaluable idea for enhancing our avodas Hashem, shalom bayis and all interpersonal relationships. It’s well worth a cold omelet.

[1] The next summer, the current director, Alex Gold, took over the camp and began the revitalization Camp Dora Golding has enjoyed since.

[2] Rabbi Mandel noted that the decision had obviously been made that he should rather attend yeshiva than have a bris. However, that was halachically incorrect. The severity of not having a milah outweighs the vital need to learn Torah.

[3] Avos 2:4

[4] Yevamos 64a

[5] And in fulfillment of the pasuk “Hope to Hashem, strengthen and make your heart courageous, and (again) hope to Hashem” (Tehillim 27:14).

[6] Devarim 3:26

[7] Sotah 14a

[8] It is well-known that Rav Chaim rules that watches are a women’s clothing and, therefore, men cannot wear them.

Rabbi Dani Staum, LMSW, is a popular speaker and author. He is a rebbe in Heichal HaTorah in Teaneck, NJ, and an experienced therapist, recently returning to seeing clients in private practice, as part of the Rockland CBT group. For appointments Rabbi Staum can be reached at 914-295-0115. Looking for an inspirational and motivational speaker or scholar-in-residence? Contact Rabbi Staum for a unique speaking experience. Rabbi Staum can be reached at [email protected]. Archives of his writings can be found at

Leave a Comment

Most Popular Articles